Understanding Internal and External Fraud Perpetrators

Every organization is concerned about fraud. In an age of increasing cybercrime, some fraud perpetrators are international criminal syndicates or even foreign government actors. But not all perpetrators fit that profile. Know your adversaries.
Drawing from the ACFE’s 2024 Report to the Nations and additional insights, we’ll explore the motivations behind fraud and typical fraudsters’ profiles and examine external cybercriminals. At the heart of this analysis is the “fraud triangle,” which serves as a cornerstone in understanding fraudulent behavior.
The Fraud Triangle: A Foundational Framework
The “fraud triangle,” developed by criminologist Donald Cressey, is widely accepted as the framework for understanding why individuals commit fraud. It consists of three key components:
- Pressure (Motive): This is the driver that pushes individuals toward committing fraud. Pressure often stems from financial difficulties, personal problems or perceived unmet expectations. For instance, an employee may feel financially overburdened due to personal debts or perceive that they are underpaid or undervalued by their organization.$1
- Rationalization: People often justify their fraudulent actions to alleviate their guilt. Common rationalizations include, “I’ll pay it back” or “the company owes me.” Many fraudsters convince themselves that their actions are justified because of perceived unfairness or entitlement. They may claim that everyone is padding expense reports, or they feel that they’re doing no harm or that it’s relatively so minor that “no one will notice.”$1
- Opportunity: The final leg of the triangle is the opportunity, which arises when internal controls are weak or non-existent. According to the ACFE, nearly every fraud case investigated involves a breakdown in controls, which creates the environment for fraud to occur. Fraudsters exploit these weaknesses to manipulate financial reporting, embezzle funds or commit other types of fraud.
Profiling the Fraudster
While no singular profile fits every fraudster, the ACFE’s findings reveal certain common characteristics. Fraud perpetrators typically:
- Hold positions of trust: Most fraudsters are not external threats but insiders—employees with access to sensitive company assets or information.$1
- Are first-time offenders: Many do not have prior criminal records and are often viewed as trustworthy before someone discovers their fraudulent actions.$1
- Act alone: In many cases, fraudsters work independently rather than in partnership or part of a more extensive network. That being said, collusion is also a threat.
These individuals often fall into white-collar categories, working in roles like accounting, finance or management, which gives them access to the resources needed to carry out fraud.
Motivation Behind Fraud: Beyond the Triangle
A closer examination reveals the variety of motivations that drive fraudulent activity. Some key motivators include:
Financial need: Individuals experiencing personal financial difficulties may resort to fraud as a solution.
Perceived injustice: Some individuals commit fraud due to feelings of actual or perceived injustice. For example, an employee may believe that they deserve better pay or benefits and thus justify theft as “taking what’s due.”
Entitlement culture: There is a growing culture of entitlement where some employees feel that they are owed more than they are receiving. Such an attitude can escalate into systematic pilfering or larger fraudulent schemes.
External Cybercriminals: A Growing Threat
While the fraud triangle traditionally focuses on internal actors, external cybercriminals represent a rising, significant threat to organizations. Unlike internal fraudsters who rationalize their actions, other factors motivate cybercriminals. Understanding who these individuals are and why they act is essential in combating external threats.
Who are the cybercriminals? There are several types:
Hacktivists: These individuals or groups engage in cybercrime as a form of protest. They are typically motivated by political or social causes rather than financial gain. Hacktivists target organizations they believe to be unethical or politically opposed to their beliefs.
Organized crime groups: These groups operate much like traditional organized crime syndicates but focus their efforts on cyberspace. Their goals are usually financially motivated, aiming to steal sensitive data for ransom, resell it or engage in financial fraud.
Nation-state actors: Some cybercriminals work on behalf of governments or military groups to steal intellectual property, espionage, or disrupt the operations of foreign organizations.
Lone wolves: These are independent actors, often skilled individuals, who seek to exploit vulnerabilities for personal gain, status, or revenge.
Motivations of Cybercriminals
- Financial Gain: Like internal fraudsters, many cybercriminals are motivated by the promise of financial reward. Whether they are conducting ransomware attacks, identity theft or selling stolen data, their primary motivation is economic.$1
- Revenge or Malice: Some cyberattacks are born from feelings of resentment or revenge. A disgruntled former employee, for example, may use their knowledge of a company’s systems to exact revenge.$1
- Political and Ideological Agendas: Hacktivists and nation-state actors are typically motivated by non-financial factors. They may target companies or governments they view as unethical or politically adversarial.$1
- Thrill-seeking or Challenge: In some cases, cybercriminals use hacking not for tangible rewards but for intellectual challenge or recognition within the hacker community. In earlier days of the internet, this was often the case, but these hackers have been eclipsed principally by criminals seeking financial gain.
Conclusion
Fraud, both internal and external, is driven by a myriad of factors. Internally, fraudsters typically experience pressures, rationalize their actions and exploit opportunities, all captured within the fraud triangle framework. Externally, cybercriminals present a unique and growing threat to organizations, motivated by financial gain, revenge or ideological causes. Addressing both types of fraud requires robust internal controls, cybersecurity measures and a deep understanding of the various motivations driving fraudulent behavior. The first and most important controls are around your supplier file.
Organizations must remain vigilant, continually refining their fraud prevention strategies and controls to address both internal and external threats.
To find out how VendorInfo can help you with secure data gathering and critical verifications, contact us.


