Webinar: Fraudsters Targeting Your AP Department – Are You Prepared?

Hello everyone and welcome to today’s webinar, “Fraudsters are Targeting Your Accounts Payable Department. Are You Prepared?” My name is Mark Brousseau and I’m pleased to be your co-presenter for today’s webinar, which is sponsored by Vendor Info. I have just a few housekeeping notes to go over before we officially get started.
To ensure call quality, everyone’s voice lines have been muted today. We encourage you to ask questions throughout today’s webinar. To do so, simply use the Q&A tool on your screen to submit your question to me. We’ll answer as many questions as time allows. Finally, an on-demand recording of today’s webinar will be sent to all of you automatically within the next few business days. We encourage you to share it with your peers and coworkers.
Today, I’m excited to be joined by Phil Binkow, the Chief Executive Officer at Vendor Info. Hey, Phil, thanks so much for joining us. Thank you, Mark. It’s great to be here. If it feels like your organization’s risk of payment fraud is higher these days, well, you’re not imagining things. In a recent study conducted by the Association of Financial Professionals, they found that most organizations have experienced attempted or actual payment fraud within the past year.
A recent study by the Institute of Finance and Management (IOFM) found that organizations report that their risk of fraud is higher now than just three years ago. In fact, 40% of organizations surveyed by IOFM reported experiencing multiple attempted or actual cases of fraud within the past year. What’s most staggering is that one quarter of organizations that have experienced multiple cases of attempted or actual fraud say they’ve experienced a dozen or more instances of attempted or actual fraud within the past year.
During today’s webinar, we’re going to show you how to stop fraudsters in their tracks by fortifying the defenses in your accounts payable department, the last line of defense in most organizations for securing your financial assets. We’ll show you the latest fraud schemes being used by high-tech conmen.
We’ll show you how traditional bank account verification processes may be unwittingly leaving your AP department at risk. We’re going to provide you with best practices for verifying the ownership of bank accounts, whether they’re domestic or international. We’re going to share with you some key considerations when evaluating bank account verification solutions.
Phil’s going to provide you with a live demonstration of one solution that can help mitigate your organization’s risk of falling victim to cyber attacks and fraud. And of course, we’re going to leave time for your questions.
Today, AP managers say that the risk of payment fraud is the number one concern that they face in their departments. That’s no surprise; Interpol, state’s attorneys general, even the FBI are all sounding the alarm. They’re saying that the risk of fraud today is higher than ever before, and they’re placing blame in many cases on the way that we’re doing things in AP departments.
Our shift to remote working disrupted hardened policies and procedures for how it is that suppliers are onboarded, invoices are approved, and payments are made. Today our cyber criminals know this. It used to be that payment fraud was really a brute force activity. I’m old enough to remember when we all said that if only we could get rid of these paper checks, then fraud would go away. Well, the volume of checks that we’re making to suppliers today has decreased, and yet fraud continues to go up. In fact, the rate of check fraud is even going up.
What gives? Well, today we’re facing a new threat. It’s no more just about intercepting paper checks in the mail, although checks still remain the riskiest way to pay suppliers. Today we face a new threat: high-tech conmen, in some cases funded by rogue nations, who are using sophisticated technologies against us. In many cases, the same technologies that we’ve been slow to adopt in our AP departments.
Now we’re seeing the risk of payment fraud increasing, and against this backdrop, organizations must strengthen the way that they go about onboarding suppliers, approving those invoices, and making payments. Most of all, we’ve got to find ways to plug the leak of the way we go about verifying bank account ownership.
If it feels like your risk of fraud is higher these days, well, you’re not alone. There’s a number of reasons that it feels riskier these days. First and foremost is corporate America’s dependence on email. I know, I know. When you were sent out of your offices during the pandemic, using email for AP processes made sense. It was a good workaround. Well, I’d argue that email is a workaround that no longer works. The fact is email isn’t secure. It doesn’t provide segregation of duties. It doesn’t provide chain of custody assurance. There’s no audit logging of activities taken on documents sent through emails. They’re easy to intercept, and there’s no retaining of documents on your company’s schedule. The fact is that email creates lots of opportunities for fraudsters to exploit vulnerabilities. In many cases, they’re using it as the entry point for payment fraud. But it’s not just email that’s being used against us.
Fraudsters these days are far more sophisticated. They’re using technologies such as artificial intelligence against us. You probably read a lot about so-called deepfakes, technology powered by AI that could mimic images or even someone’s voice. It enables fraudsters to constantly evolve their tactics. Plug one gap in your AP process and fraudsters can use technology to identify another. We also see more and more cases of data breaches and identity theft. We can thank email for this in many cases. It was a treasure trove of data that fraudsters are ready to exploit. If you’ve been the victim of a data breach and you haven’t seen payment fraud, that doesn’t mean you’ve dodged the bullet. It just might mean that the fraudsters are waiting for a convenient time to use that data against you. The so-called dark web is loaded with information from businesses just like yours that fraudsters are eager to sell.
We also find that in many organizations, we have weak security measures. Now, IT folks might bristle at this comment, but while most companies have spent lots and lots of money on hardened firewalls around their finance systems, the systems and processes that reside within that ring are decidedly less secure.
I’ll give you a good example. I recently had dinner with the CFO of a large property management company. He shared with me that his company had recently been the victim of a ransomware attack. Fraudsters infiltrated his system, stole his data, and held it ransom until the company handed over a check for $480,000. Well, it turns out that there’s a If you’re willing to write them the check, they’ll tell you how they infiltrated your system and you have 30 days to plug the leak or else all bets are off and they’ll come back at you. Well, it turns out that in this property management company, one of the largest in the companies, one that had invested hundreds of thousands of dollars in security, they happened to have a PC running Windows 6, yeah, you didn’t mishear me, In their call center, fraudsters were able to get into the network through that PC and then snake their way all the way to the company’s financial data. That was a $480,000 lesson learned the hard way.
Global payments or cross-border payments create even more complexity when it comes to verifying the ownership of bank accounts. In many cases, organizations have insufficient staff training. The fact is most of us take what I’ll call a set-it-and-forget-it approach to training our staff on fraud mitigation measures. You know the drill: we sit down a new employee, we tell them the do’s and don’ts to help keep us out of trouble, we pat them on the back and send them on their way. Well, as I said earlier, today’s fraud schemes are constantly evolving. Fraudsters are using lots and lots of different technologies against us. So, we need to make sure that our staff is up to speed. When we used to all work in the office, we could stand around the water cooler and count on one of our employees sharing a story. You know how it goes. You’ll never believe what someone tried to pull on me today. Everyone listening to this story would file it away in the back of their minds, and they’d know what to look for if they ever saw that scenario again. Well, now that we’re working remotely, at least part of the time, we don’t have that water cooler conversation. So it’s up to us to find ways to make sure we keep our staff up to speed. Put it all together and it’s no surprise that AP leaders believe the risk of fraud is higher these days.
There’s a number of schemes that fraudsters are using against us to try and rip off our AP departments. The most common scheme, the one we experience in our consumer lives, are phishing scams. Now these aren’t the unsophisticated scams of yesteryear. You know, a Nigerian prince who wants to wire us five million dollars, all we have to do is send them our credit card number and they could get things underway. Today’s phishing scams are far more sophisticated. They mimic legitimate suppliers or even legitimate technology providers. Perhaps you’ve seen an email that reports to be from your ERP or accounting software provider. It doesn’t look quite right, but it’s asking you to update your credentials to log into that system. Or maybe it’s from your bank or maybe it’s even a senior manager who forgot their login and wants to borrow yours. Whatever the scenario, the fact is fraudsters are using our dependence on email to try and get our credentials and once they’re able to do that then they have the keys to the kingdom. And it’s not just us we have to worry about. In some cases they’re hacking our suppliers and then they can generate invoices with different remittance addresses or they can ask you to send you an email that comes from their URL and asks you to update the login credentials for their portal. Now, again, they can do their nefarious activities.
We’re also seeing an increase in business email compromise, the fastest growing instance of fraud. These are cases where fraudsters impersonate legitimate suppliers or senior management and urgently ask us to change banking account details or else the supply chain will crumble to its knees. In many cases, these started with email, but now we’re seeing more and more cases of business email compromise schemes leveraging text and in some cases voice.
One case, I heard of a finance director who was sitting next to their CFO at a meeting and received a text purportedly from the CFO saying we needed to urgently wire this money. These are laughable examples, but if one employee cuts a corner and doesn’t check all the details, we could see that money be quickly lost. We also see cases of account takeover in those instances where fraudsters are able to get the credentials to our systems. Now they’re able to affect transactions in our ERP or a banking system without our knowledge. We’re also seeing an increase in invoice fraud. I already spelled out one of the scenarios where a hacker will infiltrate a supplier’s systems and send out an invoice with slightly different bank account details or a remittance address, and if you’re not carefully checking that information, that money will be lost. Of course, we’re still seeing lots of check fraud.
It’s the most insecure way to pay a supplier. I’m not going to lecture you about all the reasons you need to stop cutting paper checks. But I want you to consider this. Here in Philadelphia, one of the largest cities in our country, they tell us not to put paper checks in those blue mailboxes that are on the corner of, well, just about every other street corner in this city. The fact is, you can go on the dark web and buy the keys to those mailboxes. Empty the mailbox and go ahead and whitewash those checks. Last summer, we had a rash of instances where fraudsters were assaulting our mail carriers to steal their keys. I always tell folks that my mail carrier, Joel, is a former MMA fighter. So if they tried that on him, they probably would get more than they bargained for, but that’s not always going to be the case. When you put all these schemes together, this is what we’re facing as AP leaders. This is what we’re up against.
One of the most nefarious ways that fraudsters are trying to rip our companies off is using phony bank account change requests. In many cases, fraudsters do some reconnaissance. They’ll go online and target some companies. Using social engineering, they’ll identify who or some of the people within the organization that they want to try and use their scheme against. Using phishing or spoofing or other tools, they’ll send illegitimate emails to the target trying to get them to give up credentials or they’ll go ahead and try to win over their trust. They’ll in some cases impersonate a supplier through social engineering, they’ll know exactly who you deal with at your supplier.
Using a URL that might look very close to the one that you are familiar with for that supplier, they’ll go ahead and try to win over your trust. Once they believe that they’ve got the foundation laid, they’ll submit that fraudulent change request on behalf of a supplier, or maybe even a stakeholder within your organization, say someone from procurement or maybe your CFO.
If someone cuts a corner, if they don’t verify the ownership of that bank account, that money will be deposited into an account that the fraudster controls. Before you know it, it’s whisked away in many cases to bank accounts in faraway countries where it’s very hard to recover. Today, less than half of all funds that are sent to fraudsters are ever recovered. Phony bank account change requests are a significant risk for AP leaders today.
The cost of falling victim to any of these scams, whether it’s a phishing scheme, an account takeover, or a phony bank account change request, can be significant for an organization. Of course, we focus on the direct financial losses and rightfully so. Businesses are losing millions of dollars in some cases to fraud schemes. But payment fraud can hurt our companies in other ways. It could strain our relationships with suppliers. It could have them wondering whether we’re really a trustworthy business partner. If we’re in a highly regulated industry, it could cause significant financial penalties, fines, or even put our business at risk.
It could tarnish our reputation with investors and stakeholders and customers. No one wants to be on the front page of the newspaper, whether it’s print or virtual, having been the victim of payment fraud. What’s more, left unchecked, payment fraud can cause our business to lose its stock standing. What’s really risky about all of this is that the way we go about doing things in accounts payable is often leaving our companies unwittingly vulnerable to the types of schemes that I described today.
Think about the way that we go about verifying the ownership of those bank account details I just spoke of. It takes a lot of time to verify bank account details, particularly now that a lot of our business partners are working remotely. Who answers a phone? Who answers an email? There’s also lots of cases where they could be susceptible to human error. I know you have seasoned employees who are trustworthy and wouldn’t intentionally do something wrong, but the fact is they could have a bad day. They could overlook something. They could become so overburdened with their job that they get mixed up. Simple keying error or something overlooked can result in a significant financial loss. What’s more, the way that most of us go about verifying bank account ownership is hard to scale. It’s dependent on that seasoned employee. As our business grows and the volume of bank accounts we need to verify grows, now we’ve got to add more people to it.
The more people we add, the more points of failure that might be, and they might not be as seasoned as the staff we already have. Finally, our traditional processes for verifying bank account ownership don’t have real-time validation. I already told you they take lots of time, and that gap between when we supply that information and we verify the details, well, that’s a window that fraudsters can use against us. The sooner we can verify information, the sooner we can make sure that we stop fraudsters in their tracks.
Verifying international bank account ownership is even harder. There’s no mistaking it. Different countries have different banking systems. In many cases, there’s limited access to real-time verification tools. Some of the tools we use for verifying domestic bank accounts simply might not be available using standard technology in other countries.
In many cases, those manual verification methods that we rely on so heavily here in the United States simply aren’t effective internationally. So how is it that we can go about protecting our payments to making sure that we’re paying the right entity? Well, the first is to train staff on fraud awareness.
We want to make sure they know the latest fraud schemes and how it is that they can help mitigate our risk. Whether it’s using your corporate intranet, periodic webinars, messaging to your staff, you want to make sure that they know all of the latest details of what to be aware of. You also want to make sure that you partner with your IT department to periodically test them. Make sure that they’re not opening attachments from unknown entities or clicking on links within emails, those are oftentimes the on-ramp for fraudsters to get into your network or to steal someone’s credentials. You want to create a culture of fraud mitigation. You want to make sure everyone in your organization knows it’s their obligation to help mitigate your organization’s risks.
But one of the most effective ways that you could mitigate your AP department’s risk of falling victim to cyber attacks and payment fraud is to automate the way you go about verifying bank account ownership. In the past, we used to rely on email verification, telephone verification, penny tests. Maybe we asked the supplier to provide us with the numbers of the last invoice that they submitted. These all serve a purpose. But the fact is the most effective way to ensure that you’re paying the proper entity is to automate the process of verifying bank account ownership.
Today, self-service supplier portals include capabilities built right in to make that verification automatic. A supplier will receive a link from you to onboard onto your platform. They’ll go ahead and provide information about their company, just as they would in your manual environment, only it’s an electronic workflow-driven solution. Once that information is collected and it’s ensured that it’s complete, the solution will go ahead and validate that information. It’ll use different methods and technologies for verifying the authenticity of the bank account details based on eight different dimensions. In cases where information doesn’t match up quite perfectly, a flow will be set up so someone can take a look at it. It’s almost like a stoplight. Green means everything’s clear; you could go ahead and pay the supplier. Yellow means some of these fields aren’t quite right; somebody should take a look at this and just make sure everything is okay. Red means something’s wrong here; don’t pay this entity.
All of this is going to be integrated with your ERP. Once a supplier’s information is verified, an update can be made to their record in your ERP. You can have that information so you can make sure they’re payable. Today, automation is your first line of defense against fraud. Automated bank account verification provides you with real-time, accurate verification of all bank account details. It provides you with workflow consistency; there’s less chance of errors, there’s more complete audit trails, and there’s no chance that someone will cut a corner. The systematic workflows ensure that every step you’ve laid out will be followed to the tee. What’s more, integration ensures that every single payment you make is verified automatically.
As those details change over time, the solution continually verifies that information. Those new account change requests that come in can go through this solution as well. This automated technology works just as well with international bank accounts as it does with domestic bank accounts. Again, buyers are going to send an invitation to suppliers. Suppliers will register through the portal and provide their bank details. Only in this case, a number of different processes and technologies, which Phil’s going to demonstrate in just a few moments, will verify the ownership. The key is that once again, the information is done in an automated, systematic, real-time manner.
Surely you’re going to be excited about the idea of automating bank account ownership. The question is, what do you look for in a solution to ensure it’s the right one to mitigate your risks? The first thing to consider is whether it offers real-time verification. You don’t want a solution that leaves you with delays, frustrates your suppliers, and increases the possibility of risk. You want to make sure a solution has multi-factor authentication. You want to make sure that it’s making it difficult for fraudsters to infiltrate your system. You want to make sure the solution continuously monitors supplier information.
Today’s focus is on bank account change requests, but what about OFAC checking and sanctioned screening? Can the solution ensure that someone who’s already in your supplier database hasn’t become a supplier you shouldn’t be doing business with? You also want to make sure the solution is easily scalable and adaptable to your changing business needs. Your business will change—will you need to buy more licenses? Will you need to add more people? Finally, you want to make sure a solution works for both domestic and international bank accounts.
What’s the message Phil and I want to leave you with today? Well, it’s that cyber attacks and payment fraud are increasing. You’ve never been at greater risk, and the stakes have never been higher to get it right. Traditional processes, well, they’re probably leaving your AP department vulnerable to these high-tech conmen. The good news is, best practices and automated technology such as bank account ownership verification solutions can mitigate your organization’s risk of fraud. But don’t take my word for it. Phil is now going to show you a demonstration of one solution that can help mitigate your organization’s risks.
Phil: Thank you so much, Mark, and thank you, everyone. What you’re looking at now is an actual application for verifying bank account information, and we’ll talk about bank account information and also other data components that you may want to verify as well. You can use this as a vendor-facing application where the vendors can fill out all the information, and you can also use it as a back-office application as well. What happens is whether it’s one of your staff or whether it’s the vendor, they fill out a form right online. This one is for bank account information. They can select either a U.S. or a non-U.S. bank; the appropriate fields display when that information is to be entered. They sign the document and submit it. For domestic bank account verifications, it’s instantaneous; internationals can be instantaneous or it can take a little longer depending on the country. What you’re able to do is immediately see exactly what the status and the owner, whether or not the owner of that bank account is the vendor. In this particular case, as Mark mentioned, we’ve got green, yellow, and red. I’ll show you a green one and a yellow one. This is an actual bank account. There’s an eight-point match with routing number, an account number, and then company name, address, city, state, zip, and TIN.
There’s also a Google map that will show you a picture of the location and also a map of the location. In this particular case, everything’s green and you’re good to go. On the other hand, if we take Crazy Jim’s Pizza over here, this one’s yellow, so there’s a problem. The problem here is while it is a real bank account, it’s green, there’s a problem with the supporting information. The name is under Crazy Jim’s Pizza, but the address, zip, and TIN have alerts. This means that there’s an error in the matching, and the warnings for the city and the state indicate there’s an even bigger discrepancy there. This one would take a little bit extra effort to go out and make sure you’re actually paying the right vendor. All of this is documented.
You know who did what and when they did it. Complete audit trails are available. You can also use this not just for bank account information, but for W-9s and W-8s. You can have the vendor fill out a substitute W-9, which can save a form if any of you are using substitute W-9s. You can also have them fill out the actual W-9, which the system keeps up automatically as those forms change by the IRS. If you’re doing anything internationally, the system has a wizard that actually walks the supplier through 16 pages in about 20 seconds of IRS instructions to make sure that they’re filling out the correct W-8. You know, there’s several of those. Vendors don’t always know which ones to use, and they submit the wrong one, and they don’t fill them out appropriately. In 15 seconds, I answer the questions, I came up with a BNE, and then the system actually helps them fill out the BNE by helping them go to the appropriate parts based on the answers that they’re submitting into the form itself. Unlike W-9s, as you know, if you’re processing W-8s, W-8s have to be resubmitted every three years. The system keeps track of that and allows you to automatically decide who you want to send reminder notices and links back to the vendor to resubmit their W-8 three years later. You can also do that with other forms as well, such as Certificates of Insurance, for example. If you’re using this in addition to bank account verification for collecting things like W-9s, taxpayer information, and other data, let me just show you here. You can have this vendor-facing, as mentioned, whatever your form is that can be duplicated on the site. You can have drop-down menus and pop-up menus based on different criteria that you might want different types of suppliers to provide. They can upload documents such as insurance certificates or certifications, voided checks, letters from banks. When they do that, that information is verified as well. For example, here, this is showing TIN and address and sanctions screening information. Once again, green is good. In this particular case, there’s about 50 lists here.
We’re adding more every probably in the next three or four months it’ll be closer to a hundred, but you’ve got sanctions and address and government lists checking the TINs making sure that the TIN actually matches with the IRS database. If there was a glitch and they didn’t provide you with the correct TIN, that would show up here in red. The system actually gives you the capability to follow right up with those folks and ask them to provide the correct information. It’s all within the system itself. The system has extensive reporting. You’re able to see which, if you’re using this as a vendor-facing portal, you’re able to see which vendors are in process, which documents they’ve submitted. Automatic reminders can go out to them to you as well and keep them on track. It really gives you a way to collect information and verify information, track what’s collected without the emails and the manual interfaces that normally go with legacy vendor onboarding procedures. It’s very secure because it’s eliminating, well, one reason is because it’s eliminating the email opportunities for threat actors to get engaged. It’s also a secure system within itself. One of the questions that we often get asked is, can this upload data into our ERP system? The answer is it does provide uploads as well to any ERP system.
So I know that was kind of quick and folks may have questions. Mark, I think we still have enough time to actually answer a few questions. We do indeed. If you haven’t already submitted your question for Phil or if you’ve thought of another question for Phil, go ahead and use the Q&A tool on your screen to submit your question to me now. We’ll answer as many questions as time allows. Gene wants to know, as an administrator who is approving the vendor information prior to activating the vendor in our system, is the recommendation to ensure that all parts are green? What is the best practice here? Great question, Gene. Yeah, so, and Mark, just in case anybody, we don’t get to somebody’s question, we can put the contact information up there too, so y’all can reach out to us. Gene, the answer to your question is green is good. There may be some things that are yellow based on your particular company, but red is not good. What I would do is, we can sit down and talk with you about your situation and maybe there’s some of these lists and screens that aren’t appropriate to you, but all in all, with all of the customers that we have, and there’s hundreds of them, everybody’s looking for all green, all green all the time. Marie wants to know more about how it is you collect W9 forms.
So, if the vendor, you can do this in a couple of ways. One is you can have the supplier actually fill out a W-9 right online, such as this. You can actually have your team fill in the relevant information about a W-9 to verify the taxpayer identification number. This does it with the IRS. You can have the vendor upload a W-9 and then enter the information. So it collects it, it takes it, it’s already digitized and you know for the vendor for the information that the vendor or your team puts in and it goes right to the IRS. It comes back and it’s verified or not. Usually it is, but often it isn’t. Rosanne wants to know more about your sanctions screening process. Good question.
So, for sanctions, the system checks many lists. OFAC, as you know, is really a whole compendium of lists, many lists from many different departments. It also checks international lists such as EU, UK, UN. All those lists are downloaded every day from the appropriate agency, government agency, and then the sanctions can be screened not only at supplier onboarding but because these lists change they can be screened at any you can screen your whole vendor file as often as you like we have some customers who actually screen it every day. Bree wants to know how often does your database get updated is it something that you reach out to companies to get updated information? Well, when you say updated, it could mean how often are the lists and the watch lists that we compare to updated, and that’s perpetual. If you’re interested in what the best practice is for how you should update information for your suppliers, that’s really up to you. The system can be set up to really allow the suppliers to help you keep your vendor file clean. It’s pretty cool really.
Nick wants to know the pricing model. Is this transaction based pricing or license based? Yeah, good question Nick. So the pricing is based on a few factors. One is the volume, how many suppliers are actually running through the system over a period of a year. It’s also based on the scope of work because it has a built-in workflow that allows your team to review the information and then approve it and different organizations have different workflows and different criteria for workflows, which the system can accommodate any of those. You can have any number of paths. You can have any number of levels for review and approval.
So that’s a criteria as well for scope of work. Those are the two main ones. Sometimes very, very complicated forms can impact the scope of work, but essentially it’s a volume and scope of work-based pricing. Cat wants to know how do we go about getting a demo from Vendor Info. Sure, Cat, just shoot us an email if you like either to me on the screen pbinkow@vendorinfo.com or info@vendorinfo.com. Either one will get to us and one of our customer success managers will get back in touch with you and arrange for a demo. That will be our final word. Phil, thanks so much for an excellent presentation, sharing all your insights with us today. Thank all of you for taking time out of your busy days to join us. On behalf of VendorInfo, this is Mark Brousseau. Thank you all, hope to speak with you all again soon.


